This is a repost of a cohost post from AUG 13, 2024:
Someone made a weird claim on twitter about the PS2 and how important DVD playback was in late 2000, claiming that DVD players were under $100 by the end of 2000. It didn’t smell right, but this screenshot they kept posting didn’t make sense to me. Where was it coming from, who was saying this about DVD players?
I went to try and find where this screenshot came from, and it’s the Wikipedia page for “DVD player”. I went and skimmed the 5 refs included in that article, and as far as I can tell, of the 1 webpage, 1 service manual, and 3 articles, none of them say this about pricing. Here’s the specific version of the article I was looking at.
The closest we get is the EETimes reference in that wikipedia article, an article from May 2002 which has “With DVD player prices on track to drop to about $70 by year’s end”. That’s not super helpful because it doesn’t tell us where the prices are in May 2002.
The remaining four sources aren’t very helpful either. The service manual PDF is lots of circuit boards, no prices. The webpage and and the other two articles are talking about the first year of the DVD player & format, which is about 1997. So that doesn’t help us. Where’d this number even come from?
I checked the Talk page for the article, I’m seeing someone point out in 2008 that there were 0 sources on this article, and I’m not digging in the edit logs of the article itself to see when/where the references came from. So we know sometime between 2008 and 2024 these five sources were added, but none of the sources back the claim.
Trying to find articles about pricing from the time, I google “dvd player price in 2000” and get an IGN article from August 2000 that lists prices ranging from $270 to $3,000. To confirm my knowledge of the PS2 launch (because now I’m doubting what I know lol) I find a GameSpot article from May 2000 announcing the price and launch of the PS2, which is October 26, 2000 for $299 USD.
If your entry level DVD player is $300 in August 2000, I don’t know how easy it was to find players “under $100” by the end of the year, and definitely not by the PS2’s launch date of late October 2000. Based on looking through some articles at the time, we’re looking at something that cost the same as a budget Sony DVD player at the time, but also played video games. It’s hard to say how much that drove sales, but I did a quick search for “ps2 launch sales”, looking for articles before 2001. I found a CNN article from the PS2’s launch day that says:
Perhaps the most important perk, the PS2 can play digital versatile disc (DVD) movies, a feature that Sony hopes will make the $299 console a standard appliance in North American homes. The game pad controls the DVD functions with a relatively rudimentary interface, allowing users to skip ahead, pause or view special features.
In Japan, the presence of the movie player has reportedly driven up sales of DVD movies.
Based on quick searches from articles at the time, the evidence that the DVD feature helped PS2 sales is way more evidenced than the idea of $100 DVD players by the end of 2000. Hell, trying to find something that gets me close to that pricing claim is a CNET article from 2002 which says:
The cost of DVD players fell more than $200 within two years of their introduction in 1997 for nearly $500, according to Peddie Research. And the price slide hasn’t stopped. Although the Consumer Electronics Association says the average price of a DVD player was $193 last year, consumers can now find players for less than $100.
Looking at it all, it seems like the DVD functionality was a selling point according to Sony and articles at the time of the launch, so. I don’t know, seems like the DVD feature was important to sales of the PS2!
I would have been 6-ish when the PS2 launched, so what I know first-hand of the era is skewed. Listening to people I trust talk about games has given me the impression the DVD drive and playback was important to the PS2’s sales and initial success, making for a solid foundation for people to develop a shit ton of amazing, system-seller titles for the platform. It’s a hand-in-hand situation, not an either-or situation. Based on what I remember growing up, the PS2 was a good investment for a video game household that loved movies but didn’t have the funds to get a DVD player and get a game console. For us, the PS2 was a best of both worlds situation.
But that’s kinda… not the point? It wasn’t difficult to find these sources talking about price, but it should have been easier. Articles talking about DVD player prices should have been in the Wikipedia article, but weren’t. That’s super strange to me, a Wikipedia article about a large and important type of media player has only 5 sources, and more than half of them are talking about it’s first year. Google search should have been a lot better to allow me to find more sources from the time, because it was hard to find any coverage of the launch day vibes of the PS2. Thinking about this more after the fact, I think I need to learn how to search magazine scans because I know gaming print magazines at the time would have said something about DVD playback and how important it may or may not have been!
I don’t know where to end this. Seems like there’s a weird bit of misinfo on the DVD player Wikipedia page, which seems hard to correct because I’m not sure where to look for better sourcing. Someone should do something about this I think!